In order to support the emerging culture of sharing copyright protected works alternative reward systems and cultural flat rate models should be explored.
Recommendation 14 has not been implemented. Since we have issued this recommendation we have seen massive changes in the way cultural expression and exchange are taking place online. The current model is highly unsatisfactory and is in need of being replaced by a system that ensures a fairer distribution of the economic benefits of cultural expression and exchange online. In this light this recommendation is still extremely relevant, although any real solution likely requires intervention way beyond copyright alone.
Learn more→
Learn more→

Recommendation
In order to support the emerging culture of sharing copyright protected works alternative reward systems and cultural flat rate models should be explored. The current debate about copyright is dominated by a narrow focus on the business models of the entertainment industry. As part of this discussion rights holders advocate more extensive copyright protection and more stringent enforcement in order to ensure the survival of business models based on selling access to copies of protected works. While there is no evidence that extended copyright protection and/or stronger enforcement will allow these business models to continue to exist, there is clear evidence that any extension of copyright protection will harm our ability to access our shared knowledge and culture. Instead of focusing on an extension of copyright protection and enforcement alternative rewards systems and cultural flat rate models should be explored. These systems are in line with the emerging of a culture of sharing that attempts to maximize access to and interaction with cultural works.
Implementation
Recommendation 14 has not been implemented. Since we have issued this recommendation we have seen massive changes in the way cultural expression and exchange are taking place online. On the one side we have seen the emergence of subscription services for music, video and other forms of cultural expression that have created new sources of revenue for creators. We have also seen the emergence of new creator cultures that rely on advertising driven platforms to distribute and sometimes monetize their creations. Copyright plays an important role in these business models but the division between creators and users is increasingly becoming blurred. Economically the current model benefits the dominant platforms, global entertainment conglomerates and a small number of stars that command huge audiences while many creators continue to struggle. This status quo is highly unsatisfactory and is in need of being replaced by a system that ensures a fairer distribution of the economic benefits of cultural expression and exchange online. In this light this recommendation is still extremely relevant although any real solution likely requires intervention way beyond copyright alone.
As we embark on our second decade, it is time for us to set ourselves renewed policy objectives to preserve the public domain and increase access to and re-use of culture and knowledge. Over the next months we will convene key stakeholders to define a new set of policy objectives, which will guide our work in the coming decade.
10
Years
In order to support the emerging culture of sharing copyright protected works alternative reward systems and cultural flat rate models should be explored. The current debate about copyright is dominated by a narrow focus on the business models of the entertainment industry. As part of this discussion rights holders advocate more extensive copyright protection and more stringent enforcement in order to ensure the survival of business models based on selling access to copies of protected works. While there is no evidence that extended copyright protection and/or stronger enforcement will allow these business models to continue to exist, there is clear evidence that any extension of copyright protection will harm our ability to access our shared knowledge and culture. Instead of focusing on an extension of copyright protection and enforcement alternative rewards systems and cultural flat rate models should be explored. These systems are in line with the emerging of a culture of sharing that attempts to maximize access to and interaction with cultural works.